I’m having an identity crisis. I think I’m one thing, or at least
look like one thing, but to others, they seem to think I’m something else entirely.
And now I can’t be sure what I am. Is it me? Am I deluded? Am I not what I see in the mirror? Or is it the others? Have
they got it wrong?
So, I imagine, runs the internal dialogue of a Scottish raspberry, recently injected with the essence of salted caramel to form the finishing touches to a ‘chocolate sponge pudding’ that actually tastes of marmalade and ginger.
Ok, so for one, raspberries don’t have mirrors. And two, they probably aren’t the most philosophical of thinkers. However, the point still stands (at least in my head it does) – what’s wrong with a raspberry that tastes of raspberry, and celebrated precisely because it tastes so raspberry-y? Molecular gastronomy is mind-bogglingly impressive, but, should it be the new ‘thing’ that high-end restaurants ‘do’?
Sometime before you and I got to know each other, The Boy booked us a table at North Road restaurant. In one of the many hours I spend reading and thinking and reading some more about food, I had happened across some reviews of this restaurant, and it sounded right up my street. One review recommended North Road if you have a penchant for raw food. And, my dear reader, I certainly do.
NO, WAIT, DON’T GO. Please don’t misinterpret that as me being a follower of a raw food diet. I shall never be willing to try said regime because you can’t eat pasta raw, nor can you eat bread or cheese raw. And why on
earth would I voluntarily give those heaven-sent pleasures up!? It’s more that I love a good crunch, and what is better for crunch than raw broccoli, carrots, celery, beans…?
So, yes. We had a table, and we went and we ate. And we left, and we…were confused. I think it was a naïve first fumble into the nooks and crannies of molecular gastronomy. (Or at least a menu heavily influenced by it.) And like so many naïve first fumbles, it left me rather dissatisfied.
So what did we eat? Well.
Starters
Me – Scottish hand-caught scallops, carrot, sea buckthorn & buttermilk.
In layman’s terms: scallops (beautifully cooked. Soft, plump, pearl-coloured flesh with a barley hued outside); two baby carrots, roasted; two julienne strips of normal sized raw carrot; and a few rounds of an orangey sauce that I assumed was carrot puree, but didn’t know as there was no noticeable taste. The buttermilk was a dribble across the plate. The orange sauce, I soon found out, was the sea buckthorn.
What’s sea buckthorn, I hear you ask.
Luckily I overheard a waiter launch into a lengthy yet highly informative explanation of this berry, “found on the Scottish highlands, from a bush with
immensely large thorns, making its collection
exceedingly time-consuming and painful, more so because the berry is
extremely fragile so can often burst as it is picked. One tiny berry contains more Vitamin C than an orange, and the juice itself is very sour and tart.” (Really?) “A taste of this juice in its natural state is
of course possible Madam – the kitchen is happy to oblige…”
The ooo’s and aaaaah’s that later came from the diner sipping a shot glass of this juice made me realise that either she was a chronic faker (so many of them are), or the process of whatevering the berry to make my sauce had stripped it of its oooo-factor.
The Boy – Burnt, cured mackerel & cucumber, buttermilk & dill.
In layman’s terms: two thin fillets of cured mackerel, with one side very black with ash. Underneath was beautifully soft and tender mackerel flesh, completely different from its rough, heavy skin. Around this was a pool of buttermilk with finely chopped dill, and wafer-thin rounds of cucumber.
Verdict – both starters were delicious. The Boy’s was a tremendous balance of black, ash-heavy skin, soft dove-grey flesh, and a cool, yet sharp dairy and cucumber accompaniment. Had I not heard the spiel about buckthorn and realised the shadow of its former self that lay on my plate, I too would have though my starter was well executed. Everything was cooked to perfection, and whilst the tastes were all fairly main-stream in comparison to The Boy’s, it was a plate of food made enjoyable by the skill of the hand that cooked it. My favourite kind of plate.
Mains
Me – Norfolk venison & smoked bone marrow, beetroot in textures & wild sorrel.
(The restaurant’s signature dish).
In layman’s terms: cylinders of venison, rolled in the same ash-coating as the mackerel; rounds of wafer-thin beetroot, cubes of cooked beetroot, a small cube of bone marrow (note the singular), and a few sprigs of sorrel.
Very sadly, this was a let-down akin to realising that Rihanna can’t sing live. The venison was so over-cooked, it was like eating a rubber bung. Combined with the thick ash-coating and you have a mouthful that clung and fixed your jaw together. The lack of seasoning on the meat or coating exacerbated the clag-factor.
As for the accompaniments, beetroot will always be just a texture and provide little for the taste bud, and on this plate it was wholly uninteresting. The wafer-thin rounds weren’t crispy, so there was no great texture contrast between that and the cooked cubes. Nor was there a taste difference – no pickling or seasoning or anything. The bone marrow was miniscule: a tiny cube, about half the size of the beetroot cubes it sat amongst, visually identical. The sorrel was literally two leaves, and therefore added nothing.
The Boy - Herefordshire quail & wild mushrooms, flowers & wild herbs.
In layman’s terms: Roast chicken(ette), sautéed wild mushrooms, edible flowers and a thin mushroom consommé/gravy masquerading as a mushroom ‘broth’, and a roasted parsnip sliver or two.
Cooked well and presented elegantly, but nothing to write home about. The safe option on the menu.
Verdict – disappointing for both. I was genuinely shocked at how much they had cooked the venison. In any restaurant, to so over-cook meat is a crime worthy of tomato-pelting, but for a
Michelin starred restaurant it is…well, shocking.
Desserts
Me – Milk & cherries.
In layman’s terms: cherries halved and poached, cherry granita (think Slush Puppy texture, but with no E-numbers), milk ‘sorbet’ (aka ice-cream), and milk dust.
‘Milk dust’ is apparently milk, cryogenically frozen in liquid nitrogen and reformed into a slightly granular dust. Superman’s favourite.
I
think their aim was to create a texture contrast with the soft cherries and ice-cream slash sorbet. But, the powder dissolved when mixed with a liquid, and considering the granita and ‘sorbet’ were melting quicker than the South Pole, the dust disappeared along with it.
It was simply a dessert of fruit and ice-cream, but in portions sized for a borrower. I could sneeze more ice-cream than that. But, I suppose, a light and simple dessert.
The Boy – cheese board.
In layman’s terms: the one thing we
didn’t have to ask the waiters to decipher for us. Served with rye crackers and chutney. Enjoyable. Good cheeses. Washed down with an equally good glass of port.
Verdict – fine. But then I am never going to go for the excessively large and showy dessert, neither is The Boy, so perhaps we chose the quail from the dessert menu – the conservative option for thems that don’t like diverging too far from tinned fruit cocktail and Wall’s Soft Scoop.
The plates were all elegant, the staff were exceedingly polite, and the restaurant décor and ambience was restrained yet relaxing. It was an enlightening experience for me in that it showed me what restaurateurs have to do nowadays to win the attention and accolades of the critics. And how these accolades and flourishes can mean little to two South Landanas on a Friday evening hungry for some decent grub.
The kitchen seemed more tied up with the processes and techniques than with paying attention to whether they had achieved what they hoped (be it texture or taste) when the foam, dust or crisp was put into the diner’s mouth. Ingredients were transmogrified into something they didn’t need to be, at the expense of their intrinsic flavour or feel.
A ‘good’ restaurant should be one that can consistently send out plates of well-cooked food, across all the options available. If you can’t immolate the venison to perfection every time, get rid of the venison. If it means you only have three options for the main course, GOOD.
Pick something and do it well. Don’t hide behind flashy preparations and esoteric ingredients. And
always let a raspberry be a raspberry.